I Hated Breastfeeding

What's wrong with a bottle? Nada.

Busy week – so I bring you an old post I wrote back in 2008 shortly after I had my second baby:

How’s this for an honest true mom confession? I really hated breastfeeding. A lot.
The subject of breastfeeding is one rife with confusion and powerful feelings for me.  I truly believe that every new mom I know was riddled with insecurities over breastfeeding and that was evidenced by this question we all posed to each other: “Did you nurse and for how long?”

What that question really means is this: Am I a bad mother if I hate it?  or Am I a bad mother if I stop?

So you hope the other person responds with feelings similar to yours on nursing and better yet, ended up stopping breastfeeding BEFORE you did. This way you can quell your fears and stop the guilt because you nursed for longer and their baby seems fine, therefore yours will be fine.

I don’t mean this as a mommy wars issue – I never found it to be a competitive one or snarky one or reason to bad mouth someone for being a bad mom. I found it to be nothing but naked guilt and confusion amongst mothers quizzing each other for their own personal reasons.

There is so much pressure to breastfeed and so much talk in the media about how breast is best for baby and there is so little talk about what it means for the mom. Somewhere along the way, it’s like everyone forgot about her. She became a mom, therefore what is best for her doesn’t matter because only the child matters.

Where along the way did we forget that formula doesn’t kill babies?

Where along the way is the discussion that to exclusively breastfeed means the mother is held prisoner to the VERY frequent feeding needs of the baby 24 hours a day. Where along the way have you ever heard someone waxing poetic about how newborns need to eat every 3 hours (if you’re lucky) and how it takes an hour for a feed, therefore the mom is at the beckon call of the baby every 2 hours for at least the first 6 weeks?

And during those same 6 weeks, the mom is recovering from the very difficult toll a pregnancy and then a delivery takes on a body – this is not something that should be brushed aside.

When does anyone talk about that on the Today Show?

Because again, formula doesn’t kill babies.

So I approached breastfeeding very differently with baby number 2. First of all – even though I was tempted SO MANY TIMES because I felt myself teetering on the edge of guilt, I REFUSED to ask any of my friends how long they nursed for and when they gave it up and why.


I’m sure I knew the answers because I asked them first time around or they’ve done it since, but frankly I couldn’t remember and guess what – IT WAS IRRELEVANT.

Forcing myself to follow that rule was very liberating and empowering because it forced me to stay focused on making a decision that I thought was best for my sanity, not just my new baby.

I also went into it just knowing me – knowing me as a mom, knowing the needs of my older child and how to keep my sanity. Part of keeping my sanity and therefore my ability to still be a good mom to my older child, meant sleep – which meant that I wasn’t going to be the only person feeding the new baby 24/7. So right out of the gates, I only nursed her three times a day during times when I knew the older daughter would be at school or sleeping – therefore I could focus on baby. This also gave me freedom to move about my day and not have to worry about whipping out a boob in public – something I am not comfortable with.

Also I am a believer in sharing of duties – and why in the hell should or would I be the only person getting up in the middle of the night to feed the baby?  Yes, going to work is hard, but so is staying home with two kids – therefore we both needed sleep, therefore we took turns on splitting the middle of the night feeds. I’m not the gal who lives in a house with a husband slumbering away while I’m up. No sirree. NO way. NO how.

So back to nursing.  On Christmas Eve, I came down with mastitis – and if you’ve ever had it – you know it is a miserable, horrible thing to deal with when you have a three week old.  Combine that with a lack of sleep and an excited toddler up at 5am on Christmas morning and you think throwing yourself off the roof of a house is a good idea. Merry F*ing Christmas, was how I felt.

As soon as I learned I had mastitis and not the flu, I stopped nursing completely and just pumped. And I was very OK with that decision.

By 13 weeks, I’d hurt my back and the Excedrin I needed meant I couldn’t give her the breastmilk and guess what – the Excedrin won out over the pumping – and I stopped.

Truthfully, I was really proud of making it 13 weeks even though she never really had my milk exclusively.

My point in all of this – the whole experience was a lot less stressful because I worked very hard to TUNE OUT all the white noise around me about breastfeeding and I refused to allow myself to quiz others to assuage my own insecurities.  We’ve got some kind of crazy cultural obsession with perfection in motherhood that begins with the breast – and I really think it creates a lot of unnecessary stress and confusion for an already tired and hormonal mom.

So I read the new article about nursing in the Atlantic Monthly with great interest. Of all the things Hanna Rosin says, she really struck a chord with me when she points out that everyone talks about how breastfeeding is free – but that assumes they believe the mom’s time is worth nothing.

AMEN. Just reading that made me feel better, particularly because the high price tag on formula is always a subject in our house, I just never considered it that way. Which is so dumb because one of the first things I did when justifying the expense of a cleaning lady was point out the high value of my time and why it should not and would not be spent on cleaning. So maybe we don’t make the same argument with breastfeeding because it is about feeding our child vs. scrubbing a toilet – but again – why is it a different argument? Is our time free?

Here’s a link to the Rosin piece….it’s definitely a good read:

To keep up with  more fun, frolic and true mom confessions, “Like” Wired Momma on Facebook.

Go forth and do what works for you kittens, and tune out the rest, is how I feel about it all.

8 Responses to I Hated Breastfeeding
  1. Emma
    March 20, 2009 | 7:14 pm

    OK, so I’ll bite. I also hated breastfeeding. My situation was a little different as it was my only experience and will be (no snickering). I developed a horrible yeast infection that caused intense pain when nursing and was left undiagnosed/treated and left to grow for almost 2 months. Yes, I saw doctor, pediatrician, and lactation consultant (damn $200 bucks too) and only “my mommy and me” nurse/leader figured out what was wrong. I pumped as much as I could several times a day, because nursing was not an option (it’s not good to cry when your baby nurses – milk doesn’t flow which then leads to crying newborn). While all of this going on, my DS started having bowel issues. It was determined that he was allergic to milk (not lactose intolerant – actually allergic to all dairy). So being the good mommy, I cut out everything dairy and it still didn’t help. We were both miserable! He was gassy or constipated and my boobs hurt so much even a shower was painful.

    After much lamentation and self guilt on my part, my very hip and super granola pediatrician actually told me to stop nursing. She said that I had given him the most important thing of all – his life. I had also given him my milk for 4 whole months which was fantastic considering I had so many problems. She then told me that I should be proud of myself and to realize that the first two weeks are the most important in breastfeeding and I surpassed that.

    I got some flack from other mothers, but I told them to mind their own business. BF’ing is a very personal choice and shouldn’t be taken lightly. I did pump, so DH was in on the feeding from the beginning.

    I have no regrets about the decision I made for me and my baby. He’s a super healthy 2 year old that has just now started to grow out of his milk allergy. Formula is not the devil and bf’ing should be a choice, not a mandate.

    That is all.

  2. DC
    March 22, 2009 | 1:57 am

    KT- After living through my own bfeeding drama, I really think we set first-time moms up for failure. Before you have a baby, everyone tells you how IMPORTANT bfeeding is and how it’s perfectly wonderful, natural, magical, blah, blah, blah. So when baby is born and it turns out to be waaaaaaaaay harder than it looks in so many ways, of course the mom feels like a guilt-ridden failure. Every mom I’ve talked with has found bfeeding to be a complicated dance with some major ups and downs. If we set more realistic expectations, maybe we’d all get to spend less time crying and fretting over the subject and more time enjoying our sweet little babies who are just as happy with a breast or a bottle anyway!

  3. kelly
    March 27, 2013 | 7:55 pm

    Omg thank you! I’m currently only breastfeeding my six week old son. He has reflux and constantly wants to nurse and I know it’s because he doesn’t feel well. But mommy needs to eat and sleep and maybe just maybe take a freaking shower. I feel so guilty about stopping but I think for my own mental health it’s gotta stop. He is a 11 pound 2 foot long baby and so it’s not like I have a hand to eat with or can even get up to go to the bathroom. I’m exhausted and would really like a night to sleep while daddy feeds the baby. So thank you for making me feel that just because I want to stop does not mean I’m a bad mommy. I love him with all my heart but he needs a stable mommy not a crazy mommy. Thank you so much…

  4. Angel
    April 4, 2013 | 4:07 pm

    Wow. Thank you! I am a new mom and have only been going at this breast feeding thing for 2 weeks now but I’m definitely sure it’s not healthy for me. My newborn insists on cluster feeding all night so my sleep is slim to none. I’m feeling so guilty for wanting to quit. I don’t like failure or the negativity that come from others with it, but I have got to get out if this depressing slump. My sanity is at stake.. That can’t be healthy for either of us:(

  5. Ana
    April 25, 2013 | 10:29 am

    You say that we have forgotten that formula doesn’t kill babies. Very dramatic. Except that if 90 percent of all moms nursed their infants, an estimated 911 US babies would not die. http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/early/2010/04/05/peds.2009-1616.abstract

    That’s deaths prevented… I couldn’t even begin to comment on health detriments.

    • brandi
      May 12, 2013 | 10:17 pm

      Ana get off your high horse please. These women are complaining about things wrong with their bodies and minds due to breastfeeding and you’re trying to make them feel even worse than they already do. I’m sure you probably don’t even have kids, and are just a lonely, sad, troll of a woman.

  6. Kayla
    May 15, 2013 | 12:50 am

    Thank god for your honesty! Our first was FF at 4 weeks due to never latching properly. Our second has been BF and I have NEVER felt that connection with it. I feel like a friggin dairy cow and I’m loosing my mind with it! I truly HATE BFing even though our daughter has taken to it very well. I really feel that after 4 months, my sanity and mental well being deserves to be considered too. Thank you for opening yourself up so others who feel the same have a place where they aren’t judged. I truly feel that we as mothers need to matter too. BFing is not all rainbows and butterflies. It has messed with my mind more than I ever thought it would.

  7. Danielle @ tiny-trots
    January 19, 2014 | 9:06 pm

    I didn’t hate it, but I wasn’t crazy about it either. What I hated were the first 2 weeks for each child. Don’t know why, but each time it was painful and left me with chapped nips. Awful! And the only thing that saved the day was pumping. You would think nature would make breastfeeding an easier experience, not to mention perkier boobs. But I hear you. A lot of women hate it, and that’s great you did what was best for you.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL http://www.wiredmomma.com/2012/04/i-hated-breastfeeding/trackback/